Bill Kelso
(2)
The First Face of Music Continues
The Nature of American Songs
While understanding the main elements of music is a necessary step for understanding American popular music it is not sufficient. To fully appreciate popular music, it also helps to understand the nature of songs. Of the vast array of songs we hear on the radio they often differ in fundamental ways. In the following section we shall look at four key elements that often differentiate one song from another.
For instance, some songs are narrative songs that tell a story while other songs are emotive in nature expressing an emotion.
Secondly, songs also differ in their language as some have nothing but complete sentences while yet other songs are full of grunts, moans, shouts, aha or ooh ahas.
Thirdly, some tunes will supplement their traditional song format by adding a chorus to respond to the lyrics of the lead singer This arrangement is which the lead singer and the chorus engage with one another is a staple of soul music. These types of songs are know as call and response forms of music.
Finally songs may differ in how they are sung. There are certain genres of music in which the lead singer will use a falsetto voice to convey the theme of the song. However, in the vast majority of songs the singer will use his normal baritone of soprano voice to convey the lyrics of the tune
1.The Nature of a Song
As mentioned above songs can often be divided into either narrative songs which primarily tell a story or conversely into emotive songs. Emotive songs in turn can be divided into tunes which try to either express an emotion by the singer or conversely elicit an emotional response in the audience. While the difference between these two types of songs is clear, many tunes try to bridge the gap and achieve both goals simultaneously.
While a narrative story might tell about an incident in one’s life, an emotive song would be like James Brown’s tune “I feel Good” or Diana Ross’s song “We will be together” or numerous tunes by Aretha Franklin such as “Respect” or “Who is ‘Zooming Who.” In emotive songs the lyrics are often minimal and very repetitive in nature. The listener or audiences’ response to the music is often more immediate and visceral rather than cognitive. Emotive songs want to stir an emotional reaction, to make individuals feel either sad or happy or expectant that things will eventually get better.
In contrast the main point about narrative songs is that you have to listen to the whole narrative before you can grasp the point of the song. In emotive songs, in contrast, you don’t have to think about anything as the song is upfront about eliciting an emotional response from you in its claim that either “I feel good” or “We’ll be together.”
While it is important not to overstate the case, generally country and folk music is more narrative than rhythm and blues. Among the best recording artists who primarily sing narrative songs are folk artists like Harry Chapin and country singers like Bobby Gentry. In Harry Chapins song “The Cats in the Cradle” he is telling you a story about how his indifference to his son when he was younger, later comes back to haunt him when he was older. In contrast, Bobby Gentry’s song ”An Ode to Billie Joe” is about the everyday cruelty of people towards those are suffering from emotional problems and her family’s failure to see and understand their own daughte’s sense of grief..
a.Two Great Narrative Songs
Harry Chapin Cat's in the Cradle
Bobby Gentry singing Billie Joe
b. Emotive Songs. Focus on the start of the following songs.
While there are many singers who primarily sing emotive songs, James Brown, Aretha Franklin and Diana Ross are three of the best known. Amber Riley uses Diana Ross’s song to try to cement ties among her high school Glee class who are graduating and going their own separate ways.
Amber Riley singing we will be together
And an even more emotive song is Aretha Franklin’s rendering of “Who is Zooming Who.” In case you are not up on your street lingo, zooming means you are checking out somebody. In this case the singer is suggesting that someone who thinks they are checking her out, is actually being zoomed themselves.
I included two version of Aretha Franklin singing this song. The first one enables you to appreciate the unusual lyrics and language of the song. But the second one shows that this is a truly an emotive song as Aretha Franklin has the whole audience emotionally responding to her performance by standing, clapping and swaying to her singing. If you only want to watch one video choose the second one as few singers can match the personal charisma of an Aretha Franklin performing live.
Aretha Franklin Singing Who is Zooming Who
Video of Aretha Franking singing Who is Zooming
2. The Language of a Song
When songs are either narrative or emotive in nature, it often affects the language of the song. In narrative songs, the singer usually sings in complete sentences that are well constructed as the singer develops his story line.
Because emotive songs either want to express or elicit an expression in their audience, they often rely on moans, shouts, aha, or grunts to get people riled up. If you recall Amber Riley rendition of Diana’s Ross’ song, she starts off with ooh, ooh aha aha. Later when she discusses her sorrow about breaking up, there are more moans indicating her emotional distress at the moment. Similarly, Aretha Franklin starts off in “Who is Zooming Who” with the lyrics of “Ooh, boy, uh hug, ah yea and oh, yeah.”
In light of the above distinction the most interesting songs are those that try to bridge the difference telling a narrative while trying to evoke an emotional response. While most of the song may rely on complete sentences, there will periodically be shouts or moans to get listeners aroused. A good example of this middle ground is found in Michael Jackson’s song “Billie Jean.”
The song is about Billie Jean’s claims that the singer is the father of her son while the singer adamantly insists that Billie Jean is not his lover. Halfway through the song, indicating the singer’s frustration with Billie Jean, Michael Jackson just shouts. In any case the following clip is American music at its very best.
Michael Jackson singing Billie Jean
3. Adding and Subtracting Elements from a Song.
A third factors that distinguishes one song from another is its addition or subtraction of elements that are traditionally found in the Great American Songbook,
Again, African Americans often played a role in revising how American songs were often performed. One of the major factors that was responsible for this change occurred when Ray Charles and Aretha Franklin in the 1960s decide to synthesize traditional Rhythm and Blues with African spiritual or gospel music. This new sound or genre of Rhythm and Blues became known as Soul music.
a. Call and Response or Shout and Response
One elements of black gospel music that Ray Charles in particular has adopted is the creation of what are called “Call and Response” or “Shout and Response" musical songs. These forms of music evidently appeared during slavery as the foreman of a cotton-picking crew would shout out an order and the crew would respond. When black churches were formed, they incorporated this same format into the sermons and gospel music. As the minister preached, the congregation would response. Later when black churches created gospel music they incorporated the interaction of the minister and his congregation into their music. The shout and response of later gospel music was like having a conversation during the singing of a song. The singer and the chorus constantly interacted with one another, sometimes in a confrontational manner
In the following link, you can see how Ray Charles uses this format in his song “Hit the Road, Jack”. In most cases shout orcall songs involve a somewhat monotonous response by the chorus to the calls of the singer. While Ray Charles tries to explain his action, the response of the chorus repeats over and over again the phrase “ Hit the Road Jack.”
Ray Charles singing Hit the Road Jack
If Ray Charles played a major role in altering traditional American songs by adding a chorus to the singing of the song, James Brown, who invented Funk Music, also dramatically altered the tradition American song by introducing what is called a ”Musical Break.” Whereas Ray Charles added to the traditional American song, Brown tried to subtract from traditional songs by introducing a cut or break in the melody and rhythm of a song. During this break the rhythm section stops play while usually an instrumental or percussion section fills the gap.
b. The Cut or Break
This cut or break, which we will illustrate in a moment, is responsible for the term break dancing. When Rap music replaced rhythm and blues, DJ would often combine tapes of numerous funk songs, consolidating all of the break or cut sections from various Funk songs. When rap DJ played these music interludes at parties, male dancers would rush to the dance floor and perform their acrobatic style of dancing. Hence this form of dancing became known as Break dancing.
The following link to James Brown performing is interesting because it shows the “cut” half way through his song as a Sax player interrupts the song for a short solo break. In addition, like Ray Charles, Brown has a conversation with his chorus as they respond to his calls. As is obviously the case this is an emotive song as the lyrics are rather sparse. Finally in an excellent example of how African Americas tend to fuse song and dance, James Brown engages in some fancy footwork.
James Brown Singing Papa's got a new bag
After seeing James Brown use the cut in his song, Ray Charles will do the same in his song “Unchain my Heart.” Like the previous song, you can see both the use of call and response and cut in the same song. This combination of these two techniques became very popular in African American music.
Ray Charles Unchain my Heart
4. How Songs are sung.
A final point that distinguishes one song from another consists of how they are sung. In particular some songs are notable because the lead singer will use a falsetto voice to convent the theme of a song.
Before developing this point, we first have to realize that not every singer has the same range in belting out a tune. While some singers have high pitched voices, others are low pitched and yet others have incredible agile voices which enables them to sing in a variety of pitches.
To distinguish one singer from another, musicians have come up with a four fold typology to distinguish the singing style of male artists and a three fold typology to compare female singers. In general females have much higher pitched voices than men. The various distinctions are listed below.
Males Females
Countertenor Soprano
Tenor Mezzo Soprano (Half Soprano)
Baritone Contralto
Bass
a. The Vocal Range of Male Singers
1)Countertenor
The highest pitch for a man is called a counter tenor and individuals who have this capacity often sing in a falsetto which we shall shortly explain what that means. Famous singers who would be consider countertenors would be Barry Gibb of the Bee Gees or Robert Plant of Led Zeppelin.
Barry Gibbs singing Counter Tenor of Falsetto
2) Tenor
Just below the counter tenor are tenors and there are over 7 varieties of them. They all generally sing in a semi high voice. Among famous tenors would be Eddie Floyd, Justin Timberlake, Elton John and Bruno Mars. Michael Jackson is also a tenor but many think his voice is androgenous and he often hits notes that you could mistake for a female singer.
Eddie Floyd singing Knock on Wood
3) Baritone
A baritone is the most common singing voice of most male singers and would include Tom Jones, Elvis Presley, Frank Sinatra and David Bowie. Like Tenors there are many varieties of Baritones. Below is a video of Tom Jones who has a very robust baritone voice.
Tom Jones singing it is not Unusual.
Notice his unusual dance steps. He certainly is no Michel Jackson.
4) Bass
Finally the last singing style for males is called bass but is pronounced base. Since in everyday parlance the base of a building in the bottom floor, base means the lowest pitch of singing. Singers noted for their low voices would include Barry White and Tennessee Earnie Ford. If you are our age you should remembers Ford’s country pop hit “Sixteen Tons.”
Video of Tennessee Earnie Ford singing 16 tons
Why the Preference for Falsetto
Now that we realize that singers can vary in the way they sing a song, we need to ask why falsetto is often a very popular way of presenting a song.
Certain groups often believe that a falsetto best reflects their larger purpose. For instance, the Catholic church thought that when their choir sang in a falsetto it was comparable to heavenly angels singing. When some of their best singers from choir started to grow up and their voice changed, the church often had them castrated so they could continue to sing like the angels.
Similarly, many forms of country music such as Bluegrass as well as Black Gospel as well as Rhythm and Blues singers and Doo Wop groups make extensive use of falsetto. Why is that? We know that when people become excited or emotional, the pitch of their speech becomes much higher. For singers who are belting out emotive songs, they often believe that if they sing in a falsetto, their voice will elicit a more positive emotional response from their listeners. A good illustration of this point is found in Pharrell Williams’ song “Happy.”
Pharrel Williams singing Happy
A final and more sophisticated way to use falsetto is when artists selectively use it to highlights parts of a song. For instance, Marvin Gays, a very talented Motown singer is primarily a tenor. But when he is singing a love song and comes to the most import emotional part, he will temporarily resort to a falsetto to heighten the emotional intensity of his recording.
b. The vocal Range of Female Singers
While falsetto singers are often found among male singers, that terms is rarely used to describe female singers. Generally the vocal range of women singers is much smaller than men as there are very few women who can sing at the bass level. Most female singers probably belong to the group of the Mezzo Sopranos which means half soprano as it falls in between Soprano and the lower pitch of Contra Alto.
1) Mezzo Soprano Singers
Some prominent Mezzo singers would include Beyonce, Aretha Franklin Adele, Sheryl Crow, Miley Cyrus, Ella Fitzgerald, Taylor Swift, Witney Houston and Amy Whitehouse.
2) Sopranos
The two alternative types of female singers are harder to find. But there are several prominent sopranos and they would include Christina Aguilera Julie Andrews, Celine Dion and certainly Maria Carey. Of all American singers Maria Carey probably has the greatest range as she can hit high notes that are beyond the range of most other female singers
3) Contra Alto
Our final type of female singer is the contra alto and this is easily the rarest types of woman artists. But there are a few notable exceptions and they would include Tony Braxton, Cher and most notably of all Stevie Nicks, the lead singer of Fleetwood Mac
To appreciate how the way a song affects its very character watch the two following links, one with Maria Carey singing “Without You” and the other staring Stevie Nicks belting out “Stand Back.” When you listen to Marie sing “Without You” notice that she will sing the female equivale of a falsetto when she comes to the most dramatic part of the song about how she can’t live without the love of her life. In this sense Maria Carey is like Marvin Gaye as she varies the pitch of the song to magnify its emotional impact on you.
Maria Carey singing Without you.
Stevie Nicks Stand Back
Stevie Nicks’ lower pitched voice seem almost harsh in comparison to Maria Carey sweeter and softer high pitch voice.
A Brief Review
Now that we have reviewed some basic principles of music it might be helpful to consolidate these points in case you ever want to analyze either an old favorite tune or a possible new download on Spotify. In listening to a song you can ask the following questions.
1. What Genre is it.
What genre is it: Rock and Roll, Rhythm and Blues or a sub-genre of Rhythm and Blues such as Funk of Disco? We will do more on this topic in another post over the next couple of days.
2. The Singer
Is the singer combining song and dance as many African artists do or is he or she just singing?
3. The Nature of the Music.
What is your overall impression of the music? Is it stressing 1) Melody, 2) Harmony, or 3) Rhythm & 4) Beat. Is the artist 5) bending any notes or introducing new blue notes into the melody?
4. The Nature of the Song
I) Finally, is the song a narratives song or an emotive song?
2) Are the lyrics full of moans shouts and grunts or complete sentences.
3) Does the song use the African America gospel device of either call and response or breaks and cuts?
4) How is the song sung? Is the singer using a falsetto or a more common baritone if he is a man. If the singer is a female, is she a mezzo soprano or like Stevie Nicks a sub alto who can be as gruff as a male singer. Or does the singer vary his or her pitch when he or she hits the main theme of the song?
|